Most important, it appears that Dr. Crane may no longer be performing surgery in the state of California (although his medical license is still current in that state). Most doctors are cis straight men who actively do not want anyone born female to have what they have. Carson v. Crane, CGC-17-556743 was dismissed October 10, 2018. Some might find the idea of a memoir just a bit premature given that Jacobs transgender journey is, at this point, only five years in duration, but honestly, youd have to be a real meanie to object. For the record, I have seen people on r ftm and Tumblr blogs discuss medical malpractice freely: I firmly believe medical malpractice concerning transgender surgery is an area that needs more oversight and exposure as a whole. So sorry you went through all of that. Any internet searches for brownsteincrane.com result in a re-direct to Crane Center for Transgender Surgery, a practice operating in California and Texas. I wish for healing for both you and your husband, and that he is able to receive competent care in the future. Dr. Curtis Crane Dr. Richard Santucci: Texas: $11,000: Metoidioplasty, no UL: Dr. Marci Bowers : California: $8000 - $9500: Dr crane moved to a place where the . I cannot get into specifics as Ive been instructed not to because of future proceedings. A metoidioplasty is a surgical procedure that uses clitoral tissue that has been enlarged through testosterone use to form a neophallus. Trial is set for February 19, 2019. For an added bonus, prospective patients may even be able to receive a free initial surgery consultation, right there at the conference! Whos your Surgeon in Canada. They just do the bidding of big pharma and push for women and kids to transition medically and be patients for life. Your comments are far far far more dangerous than any of the others on this site. I am a transgender FTM and I am looking into the surgery. IMHO, the silence is partially due to not wanting to out transgender surgeries as dangerous (surgeons must to keep that lucrative wheel generously greased), and partially because FTMs (female-to-male transgender persons) just dont rate among the male-dominated transgender culture. (uro-genital reconstructive surgeon); Ashley DeLeon, M.D. One might reasonably conclude, then, that all of these actions have been settled out of court. 4thWaveNow contributor Worriedmom has practiced civil litigation for many years in federal and state courts. Curtis Crane also does nullo procedures for men who want the smooth barbie doll look. Since our last coverage of medical malpractice litigation against renowned phalloplasty surgeon Curtis Crane, M.D., we've received frequent inquiries about the current status of the lawsuits and his practice. No body or procedure is perfect and there are inherent risks. It is helpful to have the case number (also called an index or docket number), although a search can also be performed using the persons name, so those are provided below. Commenters views are their own and should not be construed to be the opinion of either the site administrators or the author of a particular article. This story received no media attention. What does that even mean, pimping out the victims? Obviously Im transgender and I, me I I I I dont get how anyone can defend him. What is notable is that, as of the time of our earlier article in 2018, Brownstein-Crane was a thriving California transgender medical practice. 9 known men had horrible circumstances but the amount of men with success exceeds those tenfold. At one time I was doing some research on transgender murder victims for something I was writing. Dr. Curtis Crane is a board-certified plastic surgeon who is one of the top experts in Metoidioplasty in the United States. No one here is against anyone . Others should stop though. Im also going to do a video more in detail about my comment above. In addition to the above seven cases, an eighth case, Doe v. Crane, CGC-16-550630, has now been settled (as of June 2017). These NDA provisions have, of course, come under public scrutiny as part of the MeToo movement and the Stormy Daniels affairs. In other words, it does not appear that an independent arbiter has reviewed the facts of these cases and ruled on whether the care provided either complied, or did not comply, with established standards of care. This is not surprising, since over 90% of all medical malpractice cases never go to trial. thanks you for speaking the truth, you are exactly right that these young people claiming your comments are harmfull, are doing more harm temselves. First and as this article took great pains to point out the allegations contained in the complaints are just that, claims. As is common to all United States courts, records of lawsuits and the underlying documents can be found by going to the court website for the appropriate jurisdiction, in this case the San Francisco Superior Court. Before we can confidently predict that Jacob, and peers will live happily ever after, we should take a look at another story. Im not familiar with this website at all, but got linked to this article from a transresource Its unknown whether he ever returned to full-time work (in a court filing dated March 2019, M stated that he had been out of work for the majority of the past three years). All surgeries and procedures are experimental until its proven to work. Even after 6 years I would love to die today I cannot recover from Cranes brutality and despise the transgender community activist for promoting and protecting this butcher. 4. I am skeptical of ppl saying they had a fantastic phalloplasty. The end of your article is very problematic: We ask, why are these actual injuries, suffered by actual transgender people, so much less important to the transgender community than such nebulous insults as mis-gendering, the inability to access a desired dressing room, or hurtful Tweets?. There are naked passing men with functional phalloplasty; erotic and tactile sensations, urination standing, capable erections, penetrative intercourse because this surgery was successful for them. In my experience, his representing lawyers are cruel and demeaning-with zero regard that they are speaking to those who have experienced a tremendous amount of trauma by their clients (Dr Crane) hand. This means that once he intitually screws your surgery up you have no time to contact a lawyer because he claims it is not a mistake if he can fix it which takes about a year of more surgeries (according to One of his fellow surgeons Dr. Watt he does this on purpose because he makes more money on follow up surgeries fixing his mistakes). Claim-proneness results from a number of factors, including type of specialty, age and sex; however: Compared to physicians with only one previous claim, a physician who has had three previous claims is three times as likely to have another one, said lead author David Studdert, a professor of medicine and law at Stanford. Probably 90% of guys who have great experiences just disappear into the ether and live a largely stealth life. If said poster had the last few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this is nothing new. All eight of the malpractice cases that had previously been pending in the San Francisco Superior Court have now been dismissed with prejudice (read on to understand the meaning of with prejudice in the settlement context, since this doesnt mean what some folks may assume it does). One of Crane's former patients, a detransitioned woman who underwent a double mastectomy at age 17, wrote a guest post for 4thWaveNow. ALWAYS prevails. However, plaintiff claims a week after phalloplasty, he suffered numerous complications and needed to undergo multiple revision surgeries to the correct the complications of the procedure. Celeb trans kids: Will the Gender Fairy bring dreamsor genital surgery nightmares? These surgeons are not about helping people with Gender issues it is all about $$$$ . There are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product tie-ins. Stories are important, but unfinished stories can be deceptive. Its harmful to minimize it. As is customary, there is no indication whether Dr. Crane, or his insurer, paid any damages to M. Following the 2015 phalloplasty and other procedures with Dr. Crane, incredibly, M required at least three additional surgeries. Part 3 is here. One more thing. Our reporting on Dr. Crane is strictly factual, and weve bent over backwards to be fair. This case involves Dr. Cranes performance of a stage 1 phalloplasty that subsequently acquired a large blood clot, which the plaintiff claims that Dr. Crane ignored. We all know that once the lawsuits start rolling in, it will be hard to defend the mutilation of young peoples bodies. It has graphic pics and videos and breakdowns of what I experienced. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. Dr. Curtis Crane, MD is a board-certified plastic surgeon in Austin, Texas who specializes in Phalloplasty. Bartholomew is a sociologist and Radford is a science writer. From interrogatory answers filed in the Raynor case, cited above, we do know something about Dr. Cranes professional liability and medical malpractice coverage in 2016, the date the malpractice alleged in that case was claimed to have occurred (see Motion for Relief from Waiver of Discovery Objections dated April 16, 2018, Declaration of Corban J. Porter and Exhibit D thereto): Private settlement agreements also typically include NDA (or non-disclosure agreement) provisions, in which the parties agree to keep all terms of the settlement confidential, and further agree to the payment of damages in the event of a breach. Ms case (CGC-17-560690) was, like the others, filed in the civil division of the San Francisco Superior Court under the pseudonym John Doe. (Note: Although M was repeatedly doxxed in the court records by the attorneys on all sides, we retain his privacy here, as we have no interest in shaming or causing further sadness to M [we use Ms preferred pronouns for the same reason].). What is notable is that, as of the time of our earlier article in 2018, Brownstein-Crane was a thriving California transgender medical practice. In gathering people to google him and start writing reviews on medical sites. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. (in this vid and reading the lawsuits) was how horribly crane and his team responded to obvious surgical problems. It was actually a huge stressor for many patients who booked with him there and then the team fell through (and so those on his books had to reschedule either for a later date when they got a new team on board or have to come to California. Third in a series. Part 1 is here. Research has revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane. Please if you are able to i would be very interested in speaking with you further outside of this feed. F*ck our comments section on our terrible site for giving a damn about these natal females. And given the malpractice insurance premiums hes undoubtedly required to pay, he better be making some money at all this. Moreover. The types of injuries detailed above are truly sad. Yann Wehrling, vice-prsident de la rgion le-de-France, charg de la Transition cologique, et Patrice Leclerc, maire de Gennevilliers et Prsident du groupe Front De Gauche la . Before getting into the details, we wondered whether perhaps lawsuits are a common occurrence in practice areas such as this one that involve relatively experimental or new procedures, and a patient base that might tend to have unreasonably high expectations. According to the Wayback Machine, which is the only source for information on the practice, back in March of 2018, Brownstein-Crane, in addition to Dr. Crane, employed: A photograph that appeared on Brownstein-Cranes now-defunct website. It must be hard to hear that current medical technology cannot really deliver your dream. I have been looking into the bottom for a while, and since canada approved government funding a few years ago i decided to go forth with the application for lower. dr crane phalloplasty lawsuitnifty infra stocks list with weightage dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. And we all know how things went there. These kids that are transitioning will be a much much bigger ration of suicides once they realize how difficult it is to transition and they are 25 and begin to understand how invasive and hard it is to transition. So being young isnt all fun & games, I know that. I have yet to speak with one trans man that had a Phalloplasty that worked properly or didnt suffer from grave complication. I couldn't believe he didn't interrupt me once! Looks like I just need to get my ass back over to Belgiumunless someone has someone else to recommend. The opinions expressed by individual authors, commenters, and visitors to 4thWaveNow are their own. Dr. Curtis Crane is a board-certified plastic surgeon who has a very unique background: he is one of the world's only surgeons who is trained as both a plastic surgeon and reconstructive urologist with fellowship training in transgender surgery. We cant know. Thank you. Your request has been completed. And let me tell you a few things. 2. I didnt move further with a case (for a lot of reasons but mainly because I am so tired of fighting, the lawyer advised my being past the stipulation law for filing and oftentimes wont win because of that and also his reaching the cap of his insurance payout). Dr. Crane now appears to practice in Austin, Texas, and has been joined there by Dr. Richard Santucci (together with Dr. DeLeon); Dr. Safir holds down the fort in San Francisco and has been joined by Dr. Angela Rodriguez. This just strikes me as something to say rather than attempting to engage in any way with the substance. Will be used in accordance with our terms of service & privacy policy. Shame on California Politicians! 24, US, post-phallo One commenter already described the lawsuits and another said something I totally agree with (you shouldn't get to sue a surgeon because YOU regret getting an optional surgery), but neither used Crane so I'll contribute. Second and since youve come from abroad perhaps this isnt really your area but the number of malpractice lawsuits that have been filed against Dr. Crane is phenomenal for one doctor in such a short time period. The plaintiff had already undergone a vaginectomy (surgery to remove all or part of the vagina) and a scrotoplasty (a plastic surgery designed to transform part of the female genital area into a scrotum). which composer listed below had to hide their homosexuality? Im not speaking about something I dont know about, I had one with Dr. Crane. This is a supportive place for those concerned about medical transition of minors and young adults. This case involves the truly unfortunate case of Cayden Carter, a young trans man who has endured over 20 surgeries in a thus far fruitless quest to obtain, and then ameliorate the effects of, a male-appearing genital structure. Also, there is less importance given to female bodied people, so not important enough to report. Those personally effected can say it is a terrible thing that should never be performed because they are angry and rightfully so. Dr. God bless you and yours. So we were at his mercy there was literally no one else to turn to. "Single stage" phalloplasty involves the creation of a neophallus, UL, vaginectomy, scrotoplasty, and perineal reconstruction. Phallo doesnt cure disphoria, nothing does and a phallo is not life threatening if a trans doesnt get it. This is one of the reasons I feel so sorry for the young people who are going through all this. Sigh. Theres a handful of surgeons who have decided (for whatever reasons) to focus on us and we know that we are all guinea pigs as they do their best efforts to hone their craft in a field where theres no text books or formal education. You know that phrase tip of the iceberg? From interrogatory answers filed in the Raynor case, cited above, we do know something about Dr. Cranes professional liability and medical malpractice coverage in 2016, the date the malpractice alleged in that case was claimed to have occurred (see Motion for Relief from Waiver of Discovery Objections dated April 16, 2018, Declaration of Corban J. Porter and Exhibit D thereto): Private settlement agreements also typically include NDA (or non-disclosure agreement) provisions, in which the parties agree to keep all terms of the settlement confidential, and further agree to the payment of damages in the event of a breach. [1] Interestingly, on March 7, 2019, Cranes defense counsel in this case was ordered to pay a $1,800 sanction for misuse of the discovery process.. He is negligent and not honest. Are there existing YouTube links? This is just horrifying Pied pipers wrapped in Rainbow Flags leading kids to Cluebergs surgery (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Clauberg). He is a psychopath and shouldnt have a medical license. There is no trial date set for this matter. I spent a month on a morphine drip after another doctor admitted me when Crane would not. It doesnt exist. Protected by Google ReCAPTCHA. Does it mean THAT much? Another trans old school friend of mine attempted suicide after going trans. Oliver Davis v. Crane, CGC-17-557363. Isnt there a consumer watchdog organisation that should be exposing the low success rate of these operations? Most important, it appears that Dr. Crane may no longer be performing surgery in the state of California (although his medical license is still current in that state). This will often stimulate new discussion. 6. San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon, Curtis Crane, M.D., continues his odyssey through the San Francisco court system. This case also involved urology/surgical services provided as part of a female-to-male transition. wondering if youd be willing to chat with me further? I see. Youre asserting that mis-gendering / dressing room access and online bullying doesnt cause actual harm it can and does. Further, backlash from the trans community in general. You may want to contact Scott Newgent. So please dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide: I wont believe you. (plastic surgeon); and. What we do know is that none of these dismissals appear to have been the result of a jury or other type of fact-finding proceeding that evaluated Dr. Cranes conduct and made any findings about negligence or malpractice. Most commonly, this inpatient surgery is performed in transgender men or non-binary people as a type of gender-affirming surgery. https://twitter.com/NewgentTGA/status/1278068392470159360?s=20, There is an important point that is missing. Since 2012, Dr. Crane and his team have performed more than 600 Phalloplasty surgeries. The authors also cover the Strawberry Virus in Portugal. Blog posts on the matter can be found here, here, and here. By . I understand that you had a good experience with Dr. Crane, so lucky for you. I belong to those secret and private groups to avoid the s#it like this. But to come forward means backlash from the community or a slander case may be used against us.. What we hear from other parents again and again is the fact that they know for sure their child is truly trans because this is so painful, no child would make this up, and no teen certainly would wish this upon themselves or ask for this. Why is this experimental surgery even allowed? Update: Top San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon now with 8 malpractice suits, our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape, a large-scale study using data from the National Practitioner Data Bank, all surgical partners in Dr. Cranes practice, insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Clauberg, Whats Current: South Korean women hold two day #MeToo speakout, https://wpathopenletter.wordpress.com/2018/04/04/genital-surgery-open-letter/, https://twitter.com/4th_WaveNow/status/1037791291143118849, https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/comments/apkb4r/honest_review_of_dr_thomas_satterwhite_san/, Catching up with renowned phalloplasty surgeon, Dr. Curtis Crane | 4thWaveNow. I do feel sorry for these men though, please dont mistake that I dont. Its scary, its something that many of us will never be able to bounce back from. Any time Ive gone in for any surgery as an adult, Ive been told of the risks and possible long term effects, and the decision to proceed has always been mine (I dont remember being asked when I had my heart attack 5 years ago, but that was t routine surgery but an emergency procedure, I doubt anyone is going to hang around waiting for consent in those situations). In process of getting government coverage for meta w/ crane. La disforia di genere non una cosa sola - GenerAzioneD. Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy are taking their show on the road in this new miniseries! Dr. Crane is one of only a few surgeons in the world who is trained as both a plastic surgeon and urologist and has also completed fellowships in reconstructive urology and transgender surgery. Swelling was massive the first few days but that starts to go down. I begged God for the month to kill me but unfortunately I am still alive and urinate in a broad spray with no sexual organs. . In 2014, M came under the care of Dr. Curtis Crane. Didnt know a surgeon in Canada is doing these. Many of us are silenced because 1. This is the problem, people get up in arms if someone doesnt cow down to any surgery or complications from blockers or hormones. All eight of the malpractice cases that had previously been pending in the San Francisco Superior Court have now been dismissed with prejudice (read on to understand the meaning of with prejudice in the settlement context, since this doesnt mean what some folks may assume it does). Sorry, I dont agree. This case involves a plaintiff who had already undergone several transgender surgeries who wished to replace an earlier phalloplasty with a new graft that would also include lengthened urethra. I have yet to meet someone that didnt have major life changing complications or failure at some level. If more people knew what was going on, there wouldnt be so much blind support. Set after the events of HEROES IN CRISIS and smack in the middle of "Year of the . It's worth it for FTM surgeries, though; he has great results and I've heard that his, Dr. Chen's, and Dr. Wittenberg's bedside manners are all lovely. The new penis would have a functioning urethra. Second in a series. Also, I see people daily talking about Phallo and how great it is on the internet and when I finally get to ask the if they even had the surgery, its always..No not yet, or they got something completely different than a phallo. Tags: ALT phalloplasty, bottom surgery, Dr. Crane, female to male gender reassignment, FTM, phalloplasty, Transsexual Male, transsexual surgery 2 So things have been pretty uneventful since surgery. And while one might envision a series of memoirs, detailing Jacobs life of fulfillment, its also entirely possible that this will be the first and only installment. I believe a large portion of the lack of information regarding these proceedings are due to the humiliation and shame incurred in such situations, as well as the smaller number of FTMs who seek out these surgeries. Thanks, worriedmom. Hi Rose, it looks Dr. Crane has hired a PR person, this latest video interviewed has 11 followere, but the kids wont investigate information. Otherwise, very informative article. What else can he do? It is heartbreaking that these men experienced such sever complications and it is gut-wrenching the misinformation given by the surgeon. It is impossible to understand the turmoil, desires, wants and needs of others, I get that. He seems to have the requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia. I agree and Im transgender and Ive had a phalloplasty with Dr. Crane, it should be illegal.That is coming from someone that has had one. This rubs me the wrong way. He handled me with care and performed my procedure well. For phalloplasty, there are two main options: single stage vs staged phalloplasty. The softball approach that these men give to each other slays me, trying to humanize them when in fact, they are monsters. Carson v. Crane, CGC-17-556743 was dismissed October 10, 2018. Interestingly, possibly due to potential statute of limitations restrictions, the plaintiff brought his complaint seeking damages for medical battery and promissory fraud, rather than medical malpractice. Its because of this type of ignorance. Dr. Crane now appears to practice in Austin, Texas, and has been joined there by Dr. Richard Santucci (together with Dr. DeLeon); Dr. Safir holds down the fort in San Francisco and has been joined by Dr. Angela Rodriguez. Dear Anonymous, could I post your reply on my site, thetransgendertruth.com/mysite. Although its difficult to find comprehensive statistics, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape found that 55% of all practicing U.S. physicians have been sued at least once. What is the story behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas? (Of course, the allegations contained in the complaints detailed herein, until either admitted, or tested and proven in a court of law, remain just that allegations). Also, please keep in mind that even if one has a complication (and perhaps this is why he isnt honest about them) they could fix it after many surgeries so I am assuming that under some medical legal jargon that it doesnt have to be reported if it can be resolved. So is it the case that calling attention to any victims of misbehavior or wrong-doing is pimping them out? How so? The purpose of medical malpractice is not simply to pay future medical costs that might be uncovered, or otherwise to reimburse expenses that insurance does not. It makes research harder to do but not impossible. Dr. Curtis Crane, MD is a Urology Specialist in Greenbrae, CA and has over 21 years of experience in the medical field. Second, it seems that activists are concerned that covering practitioners such as Dr. Crane will lead to increased gate-keeping and perhaps lower availability of medical care. Trial is set for June 24, 2019. Crane drags out the surgeries to repair his purposeful mistakesbeyond this timeframe. HARLEY QUINN AND POISON IVY #1. The main overall complaint I've heard from people is that he tends to be very optimistic when he talks with patients especially about post-op issues - this has led to some folks not realizing that something was as serious an issue as it was. Ive had many people tell me they had it and I found their twitter announcing the dates for surgery or they were speaking of another type of bottom surgery. Other very famous / popular surgeons operate in countries where its harder to bring medical mal-practice suits like Serbia. It is definitely worth a read! carson wentz rushing yards per game. dr. Crane practices in California because you are only allowed to sue him one year from initial incident. If you have had a phalloplasty and have a horror story or know someone who has please go to my website http://www.thetransgendertruth.wix.com/mysite. Fourth in our series featuring Dr. Curtis Crane, phalloplasty surgeon. What does this mean? Any surgon can perorm them. He charged me $254,000 for this surgery. (OB/GYN, surgeon); Michael Safir, M.D. Carter v. Crane, CGC-16-554254 was dismissed December 10, 2018. According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Dr. Brownstein retired in 2013, after having performed thousands of FTM chest surgeries and passing this extensive knowledge along to Dr. Crane. The fact that Dr. Crane has been sued for medical malpractice in connection with transgender surgery no fewer than eight times in the last two years is a highly pertinent and relevant thing for transgender people to know.