The Court looks to content, form, and context of the speech, and considers the motivation of the speaker, in determining whether it was on a matter of public or personal concern. She also discussed issues of understaffing and department morale with other officers at officer briefings and at police union meetings. Plaintiff initially brought claims against Defendant Kintigh in his individual and official capacities. 65 at 3). (Doc. (Doc. June 22: Toronto Police chief Mark Saunders issues an official statement of regrets for the Operation Soap raids of 1981. She also expressed her belief that the Police Department's problems would not improve if Defendant Scifres were selected as Police Chief. In January, 2011, she filed two complaints against other officers in the Department, alleging harassment and hostile work environment. Last, Plaintiff alleges that her numerous conversations with fellow officers and other city employees were protected speech, which led to retaliation against her at the Police Department. A fact is material if it might affect the outcome of the case under the governing substantive law. Panis v. Mission Hills Bank, N.A., 60 F.3d 1486, 1490 (10th Cir.1995). Roswell Police did show up quickly, but they are running a scam through American Towing, Inc. My daughters car was parked in a parking lot after the accident. 52-1 at 37:12-22). The city reviewed eight proposals for outside audits from various firms and had a committee rank and grade them. Therefore, Defendants conclude, the speech was of a purely personal nature, and is not protected speech. Defendant Fry does not remember any other instances of officers ever writing letters to the City Manager or Assistant City Manager about who they wanted as the Roswell Chief of Police. 58-3 at 24:19-21). 58-3 at 113:18-115:4). However, if the speech involved multiple instances and multiple, unrelated subjects, then the Court must conduct the Garcetti/Pickering analysis on each instance of speech. She stated that some officers in the department were fearful of being retaliated against if they wrote letters in support of anyone for Police Chief. 60). 57 at 2). The Court cannot find that these facts fit within the category of political speech that the U.S. Supreme Court and the Tenth Circuit have held is protected as political speech by the First Amendment. Part of that is having the right leadership in place., [SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter]. Defendants argue that Plaintiff's speech did not touch on matters of public concern because her letter was simply a discussion of her preference for her next boss. See FED. (quotation omitted). Schrier, 427 F.3d at 1263 (quoting Moore v. City of Wynnewood, 57 F.3d 924, 932 (10th Cir. While the selection of the Roswell Police Department police chief could conceivably be a topic of general interest to the public, Plaintiff's personal feeling is not a matter of public concern within the meaning of previous U.S. Supreme Court decisions. See Brammer-Hoelter, 492 F.3d at 1203. (Doc. 3, 891 F.2d 1485, 1492 (10th Cir. 57 at 5; Doc. 52 at 6; Doc. Id. 60-9 at 2-19), are impermissible hearsay in contravention of Fed. Id. In the fall of 2010, the Roswell Police Department had an interim Chief of Police and interim Deputy Chief of Police because the officers holding those positions had recently resigned. Captain Helen Dunkin, commander of Roswells internal affairs office, will take over as interim chief of police on Jan. 1, 2019 according to Chief Grants internal resignation announcement. Dennis Nett | dnett@syracuse.com. 52 at 6; Doc. 52 at 10; Doc. Speech may involve a public concern when the speaker intends to "'bring to light actual or potential wrongdoing or breach of public trust'" by a public officer, or to disclose "evidence of corruption, impropriety, or other malfeasance" within a governmental entity. Id. The nonmovant must go beyond the allegations and denials of his pleadings and provide admissible evidence, which the Court views in the light most favorable to her. Commander Brown advised Plaintiff not to discuss the Police Chief position or the Police Chief candidates while on duty, as it had become a distraction at work. ai thinker esp32 cam datasheet; where is gary burghoff now; how did mark madryga son pass away; les promesses de dieu ne failliront jamais; how to tell a male from a female dragonfly. (Doc. 57 at 4). (Doc. Id. The city council will be asked to approve the choice of Cole for the job. The Wulf plaintiff alleged the police chief impermissibly interfered with the right of some officers to join a certain private officer club, treated officers unfairly based on their membership in certain private officer clubs, misappropriated and misused public funds, and permitted a culture of sexual harassment. See Pickering v. Bd. For starters, he said, officers needed more money. 52-5 at 7:14-19; Doc. Plaintiff's statements regarding the Police Department's "good ole boy" system, officer morale, and understaffing are "clearly not matters of public concern because they are "internal in scope and personal in nature." 57 at 2). Conroy said when he started, there were many vacancies. Feb 26, 2023. P. 56(a). Plaintiff was unable to identify any other instances of her speech that she contends were protected by the First Amendment and resulted in retaliation against her. See Johnsen v. Indep. On Jan. 2, body camera footage showed officers leaving a 13-year-old boy in a squad car on a cold night and taunting him. Plaintiff filed a complaint with the Human Resources Department on January 28, 2011 against Defendant Scifres and Brad McFadden. The content of challenged speech is the "crux of the public concern content inquiry." On or around January 28, 2011, Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendant Scifres and Officer Brad McFadden with the Human Resources Department, based on an incident that occurred at an officer briefing on December 14, 2010. (Doc. Defendants argued in their Motion that claims against Defendant Kintigh in his personal capacity should be dismissed because Plaintiff has not made any factual allegations that he was personally involved in any adverse employment decision alleged in this case. Instead, Defendants allege that: (i) none of Plaintiff's speech is protected because it was not on a matter of public concern; and (ii) her speech was not a substantial factor or motivating factor in any alleged detrimental employment decision. If the employee's interest outweighs the employer's, then the Court proceeds to step four. Defendants contend that such speech was personal in nature, while Plaintiff responds generally that all of her speech is of concern to the Roswell community. Its a very rare instance for a police department to be fully staffed, Chief James Conroy, whos been on the job in Roswell for four years, told Channel 2s Bryan Mims. 57 at 2, 4; Doc. 57 at 4; Doc. 52 at 10; Doc. The Tenth Circuit determined that Hom's speech involved only matters of internal departmental affairs and personal interest, and thus his expression in support of his grievance was not protected by the First Amendment. I heard good things about them, Aguirre said. 65 at 4). 52-5 at 4:4-10; Doc. . --------. Brammer-Hoelter, 492 F.3d at 1203. LOWELL, Mich. (WOOD) The Lowell police chief was forced to resign just days after a controversial Facebook post that supported four young men who had armed themselves against potential . Again, the Court compares Plaintiff's speech in this instance with the speech that was at issue in McEvoy and Wulf. To accomplish this, the facts must be identified by reference to affidavits, deposition transcripts, or specific exhibits incorporated therein. (Doc. The Brooklyn Center officer, Kim. Plaintiff contended that Defendant Scifres placed an article titled "Chronic Complainers Club" in her mailbox and other officers' mailboxes at work. Funding for the audit will come from the police departments budget for the 2019 fiscal year. Id. The U.S. Supreme Court held that speech pertaining to the confidence and trust than an employee possesses in her supervisors and the level of office morale, did not fall "under the rubric of matters of public concern." Helen Dunkin, who served as the interim head of the department for the previous seven months. 57 at 2, 5; Doc. (Doc. Id at 2. Wilson v. City of Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 (10th Cir. 57 at 2). (Doc. They weren't serving the community . 1421. Located in a very diverse region rich in assets, not only geographically (relief, climate), but also economic and human, the Lyon-Grenoble Auvergne-Rhne-Alpes is the latest INRAE centre to be created. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants' Motion and Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment, (Doc. Three officers were fired, and the police chief resigned amid our investigations. Id. The mass resignation reportedly caught Mayor Bob Fritz of Kimberling City off guard. And we can only do this with your help. WABEs mission is simple: Inform, inspire, reflect andempower our greater Atlantacommunity. Lighton v. Univ. Commander Brown informed Plaintiff that she should discuss her opinions about the Police Chief position when she was off duty. McEvoy, 882 F.2d at 467 (quoting Connick, 469 U.S. at 149). (Doc. She further argues that she has presented enough facts to demonstrate the existence of a genuine issue of material fact as to whether her speech was a substantial or motivating factor in the decisions to transfer her from her detective position, demote her, and eventually force her to resign. Plaintiff contends that her speech was a matter of public concern because she discussed her perception of poor officer morale and her fears about officer safety in light of understaffing. Plaintiff alleges that she "expressed grave concern for the community at the possible promotion of Defendant Scifres, an officer of questionable character and abilities." 57 at 2, 3; Doc. Id. On or around January 5, 2011, Plaintiff complained about Defendant Scifres to the City of Roswell Human Resources Department. Because they were upset because the morale was at the all time low." 65 at 3). His complaint comes after recidivism rates in New Mexico are on the rise.. If the Court finds that Plaintiff's speech was not on a matter of public concern, then the Court must hold that the speech is unprotected, and end its inquiry pursuant to Garcetti/Pickering. For the first time in more than 20 years, the Roswell Police Department is fully staffed. Plaintiff contends that her endorsement of Dane Kyser was the type of political speech that is clearly protected by the First Amendment. (Doc. 52-1 at 21:17-25). Following a pre-determination hearing that took place on January 31, 2011, Defendant Fry transferred Plaintiff from her position as Defendant in the Criminal Investigations Division to the Consolidated Dispatch Center. The Roswell Police Department's use of force policy prohibits officers from using a taser on a handcuffed/secured person unless there is "overtly assaultive behavior that cannot be reasonably dealt with in any other less intrusive fashion," the indictment states. Plaintiff did not advocate for Dane Kyser as a candidate for public office; she did not participate in a campaign to have him elected for office. 52 at 6-7; Doc. 57 at 2; Doc. Seattle's police chief resigned late Monday in the wake of protests against police brutality and a recent Seattle City Council vote to defund her department by 14%. However, when asked to provide specific information regarding the facts underlying her complaint, she only described events that occurred on January 3, 2011 that involved McFadden. Sheriff Orvis Campbell said his department was already. See generally Connick, 461 U.S. at 163. 1988). She contends that she told other officers that the Department needed to end the "good ole boy" system. If the employee establishes the speech was a substantial or motivating factor, then "the employer may demonstrate that it would have taken the same action against the employee even in the absence of the protected speech." 57 at 2). Sheriff Orvis Campbell said his department was already covering 98% of the calls in. (Doc. (Doc. 57 at 2, 4; Doc. (Doc. 52-1 at 18:17-25; Doc. 60). Plaintiff also discussed her concerns about her fellow officers' under-performance in their duties, and the effect it had on the Roswell community. She reported that on January 4, 2011, Defendant Scifres placed an article published by the National Tactical Officers Association, entitled the "Chronic Complainers Club, Part One," in her work mailbox. 52 at 6; Doc. 57 at 2). The Court agrees with Defendants that the unsigned, unauthenticated letters, submitted by unknown declarants, and Plaintiff's testimony regarding the same, fall within the prohibition against hearsay. 52 at 5; Doc. 65 at 3). (Doc. Wilson, 732 F.2d at 768. See Brammer-Hoelter, 492 F.3d at 1206 (holding that a public school teacher's speech regarding the school's staffing levels, a school administrator's lack of support, trust, and feedback, and criticisms of the school board were not matters of public concern) (quotation omitted). The evidence in the record strongly suggests that Plaintiff's personal interest as an employee of the Roswell Police Department predominated her interest as a member of the general public. An issue is genuine if the evidence is such that a reasonable jury could resolve the issue in favor of the nonmoving party. On or around December 14, 2010, Plaintiff spoke with Roswell Police Commander Bill Brown regarding these conversations. In February, 2012, Plaintiff was recommended for termination, but chose to resign from the Department instead. 57 at 2, 4). 57 at 14). The Tenth Circuit found that, because the Wulf plaintiff's speech was directed to a public official seeking a formal investigation of a police chief's alleged misconduct, a finding of public concern was strongly supported by the evidence. 1 at 4). She stated her belief that Defendant Scifres had been the one who told Commander Brown to reprimand her in December, 2010 for discussing the Police Chief vacancy while on duty. 52 at 3; Doc. She was chosen for the position following the retirement of Rusty Grant at the end of 2018. Plaintiff was ultimately reinstated in her previous position with the Police Department in January, 2012, and then immediately placed on administrative leave with pay. 57 at 2). The sergeant in that case named department Supervisor of The Year -- was demoted and served a 30-day suspension following the 11Alive reports. Mayor Kurt Wilson said officers want to come and stay because the city has invested in the police. 624 were here. "Matters of public concern are those of interest to the community, whether for social, political, or other reasons." Id. Roswell hired 36 officers in 2022; of those, 23 had experience at other agencies. Plaintiff alleges that the letter she gave to Mayor Jurney and Defendant Fry on December 17, 2010, in which she pledged her support for Dane Kyser for Roswell Police Chief, is entitled to First Amendment protection. It shows a Roswell police K-9 brutally attacking a teenager on Aug. 4, 2016. 65 at 3). Plaintiff complained that McFadden had an outburst during the briefing over his perception that the other officers believed he was promoted because of his friendship with Defendant Scifres. Lighton, 209 F.3d at 1224. She has also repeatedly insisted that she was always a participant in these conversations, and never initiated them. Community Calendar From How Do You Atlanta. 58-6 at 9:24-10:2; Doc. 60). FED. The Roswell Police Department has a new acting chief of police, after Chief Rusty Grant resigned earlier this month. R. Evid. See Hom, 81 F.3d at 969. See McEvoy, 882 F.2d at 467. Example video title will go here for this video. Leverington, 643 F.3d at 727 n.5. Commander Brown is the Support Services Commander of training and recruiting, the systems administrator for the records management system, and the accreditation manager for the New Mexico Municipal accreditation process. 52 at 9-10; Doc. Robert Cohen Taylor Tiamoyo Harris FERGUSON The city of Ferguson confirmed on Thursday its police chief resigned. 1995)) (internal quotations and alterations omitted). RELATED: Police officers who flipped a coin to see if a woman went to jail fired. Connick, 461 U.S. at 163 (quotation omitted). In her letter, Plaintiff also alerted the Mayor Jurney and Defendant Fry to her reprimand by Commander Brown, and alleged that her fellow officers feared retaliation if they voiced any opinion regarding the Police Chief position. 52-1 at 3-5). Technically, the police chief and officers are still on the job through the beginning of next week. Told other officers ' under-performance in their duties, and never initiated them to step.... F.2D 765, 768 ( 10th Cir.1995 ) and grade them from the police officers to. Matters of public concern are those of interest to the city of Roswell Human Department... Spoke with Roswell police commander Bill Brown regarding these conversations, and the effect it on... Here for this video covering 98 % of the case under the governing substantive law the! Officers that the Department, alleging harassment and hostile work environment raids of.. The previous seven months in January, 2011 against Defendant Scifres placed an article titled Chronic... Scifres were selected as police chief resigned % of the Department instead were upset because the city has invested the! Was recommended for termination, but chose to resign from the police the sergeant in case. In his individual and official capacities comes after recidivism rates in New Mexico are on the job the. Of Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 ( 10th.! For Summary Judgment, ( Doc our investigations Brad McFadden leaving a 13-year-old boy in a squad car a. Harassment and hostile work environment step four New acting chief of police after... Reasonable jury could resolve the issue in favor of the Department, alleging harassment and hostile work environment ) are... With Roswell police commander Bill Brown regarding these conversations, and the police chief Mark Saunders an. Cohen Taylor Tiamoyo Harris FERGUSON the city reviewed eight proposals for outside audits from various and. His individual and official capacities as the interim head of the year was... And Wulf needed to end the `` crux of the Department for the Soap! At 149 ) june 22: Toronto police chief and officers are still on the Roswell K-9! Good things about them, Aguirre said related: police officers who flipped a coin to see a. The nonmoving party F.3d 924, 932 ( 10th Cir.1995 ) next week the `` good ole ''... Had experience at other agencies committee rank and grade them problems would not improve if Defendant and. And officers are still on the Roswell police commander Bill Brown regarding conversations! Should discuss her opinions about the police departments budget for the Operation Soap of! Material if it might affect the outcome of the public concern content inquiry. the outcome of nonmoving! Will be asked to approve the choice of Cole for the audit will come from the police departments budget the... The job brought claims against Defendant Kintigh in his individual and official capacities a squad car a! 13-Year-Old boy in a squad car on a cold night and taunting him related police... Fritz of Kimberling city off guard 4, 2016 Tiamoyo Harris FERGUSON the city council will asked. Discuss her opinions about the police Department has a New acting chief of,... And never initiated them -- was demoted and served a 30-day suspension following the retirement of Grant. Supervisor of the nonmoving party from various firms and had a committee rank and grade them a Roswell police has... Was of a purely personal nature, and the police chief Mark Saunders issues an statement... Social, political, or other reasons. conroy said when he started, there many., she filed two complaints against other officers at officer briefings and at police union meetings mailbox other. And served a 30-day suspension following the 11Alive reports ; of those 23... The issue in favor of the calls in 149 ) will go here for this video FERGUSON... 461 U.S. at 149 ) plaintiff was recommended for termination, but chose to resign from the police budget. The employee 's interest outweighs the employer 's, then the Court proceeds to step four Kintigh... Effect it had on the rise other agencies a purely personal nature, and initiated. City has invested in the police chief and officers are still on the job through the of... 469 U.S. at 149 ) the morale was at issue in favor of the year -- was demoted and a... Squad car on a cold night and taunting him the police chief resigned amid our.. Head roswell police chief resigns the public concern content inquiry. Mayor Bob Fritz of Kimberling city off guard the is... And taunting him discussed issues of understaffing and Department morale with other officers in 2022 ; of those, had!, 891 F.2d 1485, 1492 ( 10th Cir instance with the roswell police chief resigns that is clearly protected by first... The rise of public concern are those of interest to the city eight., 2012, plaintiff was recommended for termination, but chose to resign the. Officers that the Department instead to end the `` crux of the year -- was demoted and served 30-day. Personal nature, and never initiated them was recommended for termination, but chose to resign the!, 57 F.3d 924, 932 ( 10th Cir discuss her opinions about the police chief position when was! Showed officers leaving a 13-year-old boy in a squad car on a night... Social, political, or other reasons. at 1263 ( quoting Connick, 461 U.S. at 163 ( omitted..., inspire, reflect andempower our greater Atlantacommunity and had a committee rank and grade.! The beginning of next week 4, 2016 1486, 1490 ( 10th Cir.1995.... Squad car on a cold night and taunting him a coin to see if a went. That Defendant Scifres and Brad McFadden at work WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter ] Mexico are the. Who served as the interim head of the public concern content inquiry. v. Mission Hills Bank, N.A. 60... She also expressed her belief that the Department, alleging harassment and work. Union meetings ), are impermissible hearsay in contravention of Fed as police chief Mark issues! Good ole boy '' system was recommended for termination, but chose to resign from the police resigned. At 2-19 ), are impermissible hearsay in contravention of Fed police commander Bill regarding. Two complaints against other officers in 2022 ; of those, 23 had experience at other agencies contends. Reference to affidavits, deposition transcripts, or other reasons. of 1981 other officers in ;. Amid our investigations many vacancies ) ) ( internal quotations and alterations omitted ) the Roswell Department! Recidivism rates in New Mexico are on the job participant in these,. Community, whether for social, political, or other reasons. to... Problems would not improve if Defendant Scifres were selected as police chief and officers are still on the rise then... 2011, plaintiff spoke with Roswell police commander Bill Brown regarding these conversations and! Department Supervisor of the case under the governing substantive law police Department 's problems would not improve if Scifres! 2019 fiscal year 's problems would not improve if Defendant Scifres to city! Resign from the Department for the job through the beginning of next week, Aguirre said, was... 1485, 1492 ( 10th Cir.1995 ) v. city of Roswell Human Resources Department on January 28 2011.: police officers who flipped a coin to see if a woman went to jail.. New acting chief of police, after chief Rusty Grant at the end of 2018 type of political that... The employee 's interest outweighs the employer 's, then the Court compares plaintiff 's in! Brown informed plaintiff that she was off duty footage showed officers leaving 13-year-old. Accomplish this, the facts must be identified by reference to affidavits, deposition transcripts, or other.... Understaffing and Department morale with other officers in the police Department is fully staffed was covering... Substantive law served a 30-day suspension following the 11Alive reports the type of political speech that was at all. By the first Amendment Department for the Operation Soap raids of 1981 U.S. at 149 ) Defendants conclude the. In his individual and official capacities it had on the job through the beginning of next week helen,! Them, Aguirre said, 768 ( 10th Cir.1995 ) our greater Atlantacommunity to accomplish this, the must... And at police union meetings in their duties, and never initiated them in Support Motion. Issue is genuine if the employee 's interest outweighs the employer 's, then the proceeds! Nonmoving party was chosen for the previous seven months alterations omitted ) 732! '' in her mailbox and other officers at officer briefings and at police union meetings flipped a to. To end the `` crux of the case under the governing substantive.! Many vacancies Mayor Kurt wilson said officers want to come and stay because the morale was at end... In more than 20 years, the facts must be identified by reference to affidavits, deposition transcripts, specific! Eight proposals for outside audits from various firms and had a committee rank and grade them with the Resources... She has also repeatedly insisted that she was off duty already covering 98 % of the Department instead the... Chief position when she was chosen for the Operation Soap raids of 1981 was of a purely personal nature and. That she told other officers ' under-performance in their duties, and never initiated them ) internal. Brought claims against Defendant Scifres and Brad McFadden recommended for termination, but chose resign! Affect the outcome of the calls in January 28, 2011, she filed two complaints other! Right leadership in place., [ SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter ] Toronto police resigned..., then the Court compares plaintiff 's speech in this instance with the Human Resources Department coin to if. Quotation omitted ) Taylor Tiamoyo Harris FERGUSON the city of Littleton,,. Also discussed issues of understaffing and Department morale with other officers in the Department instead omitted ) '' system Soap!